#52
of the
Top 100 Wines
of the Year
 
2000 Maison Grand Cru
Pinot Noir
 
"Sheer delight,
textbook
Russian
River Valley
Pinot Noir"

- Wine
Enthusiast
December 2003

  

Wine Reviews - Sorted By Review Date

 

2004
 
April, 2004 - Wine & Spirits Magazine
In their recap of top Chardonnays covering the last 12 months, Wine & Spirits reviewers tasted 558 different chards. The top 14 wines are feature in the April, 2004 issue, and Rutz Cellars is there! The 2000 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay scored 92 points and resides in the top 3% of all Chardonnays on the market.
Wines Reviewed:
2000 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay - 92 points: 
Crisply delineated with fine detail of flavor, this cool Russian River Valley wine is firm and dry. The creamy peach flavors rise over a golden wheat edge of leesy acidity in the end, lifted and composed. Order a bottle with halibut braised in a mushroom-infused broth. (Note: This review originally appeared in the August 2003 issue of Wine & Spirits - it was reprinted in the April 2004  issue as part of the article "The Year's Best Chardonnay.") 

 
 
January 1, 2004 - Fred McMillin "On Wine" at GlobalGourmet.com
Our Top Twenty-Five Wineries of 2003
"About 500 wineries, mostly from California, were represented in our 2003 competition. Here are the 25 my tasters rated highest, along with wines that impressed."
# 20 - Rutz Cellars Pinot Noir
  

 

 

2003
 
December 1, 2003 - Wine Enthusiast Magazine
Rutz Cellars submitted six wines to Wine Enthusiast Magazine for review. Imagine our excitement when all six received scores of 90 point or higher. To top it off, our Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir won an Editor's Choice award, and our Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir was voted one of the Top 100 Wines of the Year! Click here to see all of the reviews.
Wines Reviewed:
2000 Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir 93 points  Top 100 Wines of the Year #52
2001 Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 91 points  Editor's Choice
2000 Dutton Ranch Chardonnay 92 points
2000 Russian River Valley Chardonnay 90 points
2000 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay 90 points
2000 Martinelli Vineyard Pinot Noir 90 points

 
 
August, 2003 - Wine & Spirits Magazine
Wines Reviewed:
2000 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay 92 points 
Crisply delineated with fine detail of flavor, this cool Russian River Valley wine is firm and dry. The creamy peach flavors rise over a golden wheat edge of leesy acidity in the end, lifted and composed. Order a bottle with halibut braised in a mushroom-infused broth.
2000 Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir 87 points
The lush, generous cherry and plum fruit pours out like syrup for French toast. This is big and super ripe, a dense young wine best to enjoy now, with dark-fleshed game birds roasted with dried fruit stuffing.
 
 
February 13, 2003 - Bob Hosmon - South Florida Sun-Sentinel
Wines Reviewed:
Wine of the Week - "Rutz Cellars is famous for producing some of the best pinot noirs in this country. Case in point: the 1999 Rutz Cellars Russian River Valley Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir. Made from grapes grown in select pinot noir vineyards, this California red has everything you'd expect from a French Burgundian pinot. It's filled with fresh fruit flavor but is substantial enough to handle a variety of foods"
 
 
February, 2003 - San Francisco Chronicle Wine Competition
Four out of four wines entered received medals.  See the full text of the review.
Wines Reviewed:
2000 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay Gold Medal
2000 Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir Gold Medal
2000 Dutton Ranch Chardonnay Silver Medal
2000 Dutton Ranch Pinot Noir Bronze Medal
   
2002
 
December, 2002 - Fred Barger - Ocean Drive Magazine
"The only thing more fun than having lunch with gregarious Keith Rutz is drinking his Russian River Valley and Sonoma Coast Chardonnays and Pinot Noirs. He's a sort of non-traditional guy using traditional Burgundian methods."
Wines Reviewed:
Try any of this small winery's releases that you can get your hands on. One of our favorites, the 1999 Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir, is a great mouthful of wine born of tradition and innovation. The result is a smooth, elegant wine full of black cherry flavors with hints of clove. The finish is long and silky. Come to think of it, this belongs on our holiday table, too.
 
 
October 9, 2002 - Fred Tasker - Miami Herald/Knight Ridder News
"A taste of France, right here at home. Sonoma County vintner Keith Rutz closely follows the traditions of Burgundy. The result is American chardonnays and pinot noirs with distinctive French qualities..." See the full text of the review.
Wines Reviewed:
1999 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay Highly Recommended
1999 Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir Highly Recommended
2000 Russian River Chardonnay Recommended
2000 Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir Recommended
 
 
September, 2002 - Wine Enthusiast
Three great reviews and two Editor's Choice awards.  See the full text of the review.
Wines Reviewed:
1999 Maison Grand Cru Chardonnay 92 points  Editor's Choice
1999 Dutton Ranch Pinot Noir 91 points  Editor's Choice
1999 Dutton Ranch Chardonnay 91 points
 
 
July 18, 2002 - Dan Berger - Dan Berger's Vintage Experiences
"After you taste what passes for French Borgogne Rouge for $30 or so, this wine is a revelation..."  See the full text of the review.
Wines Reviewed:
2000 Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir Wine of the week
 
 
May 15, 2002 - Anthony Dias Blue - American Way Magazine
"...lush and smooth with bright black-cherry fruit and lovely structure that segues into a long, ripe, and balanced finish."  See the full text of the review.
Wines Reviewed:
1999 Martinelli Vineyard Pinot Noir
 
 
May 15, 2002 - Laurie Daniel - San Jose Mercury News
Wines Reviewed:
1999 Maison Grand Cru Pinot Noir Best Buy
Fragrant, with juicy cherry and crushed strawberries and a hint of lilac. Good structure, but a silky texture.
1999 Martinelli Vineyard Pinot Noir  
Pretty cherry and strawberry, with some sweet oak. Silky, with some spicy notes.
   
2001
 
 
December 26, 2001 - Anthony Dias Blue - San Jose Mercury News
Wines Reviewed:
1999 Dutton Ranch Pinot Noir  90 points
Lean, racy, long and balanced with pure, lifted raspberry fruit and tangy acidity.

 

Send mail to webmaster@rutzcellars.com with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2003 Rutz Cellars, Inc.